Forgotten Game of the Year Winners That Deserve Another Look
Each year, fans and industry insiders gather to celebrate the best in gaming at The Game Awards, an event that has become synonymous with the prestigious Game of the Year (GOTY) title. While this ceremony garners significant attention, other awards like the BAFTA Games Awards and the D.I.C.E. Awards also recognize outstanding achievements in gaming. Traditionally, games that earn the GOTY title are lauded for their overall excellence, including game design, production quality, and gameplay mechanics. Yet, as time passes, some of these celebrated titles fade into obscurity, overshadowed by newer releases and trends in the gaming market.
One such title is "It Takes Two," developed by Hazelight Studios. This unique game focuses on a two-player co-op experience, where players embody a couple navigating their troubled relationship through a series of imaginative challenges. While it won the GOTY award in 2021 for its innovative gameplay and heartfelt narrative, its reliance on cooperative play limits its replayability, causing it to slip from the gaming conversation as newer titles emerge.
Beyond the Credits
Words from our Sponsor.
Another notable mention is "Dragon Age: Inquisition," which claimed the GOTY title in 2014. This action-RPG from BioWare was celebrated for its rich world-building, character development, and engaging narrative. However, the franchise's subsequent entries have not lived up to the same acclaim, leading to a decline in interest in the original game as fans grapple with the mixed reception of newer titles.
"Returnal," released in 2021 by Housemarque, is yet another example of a GOTY winner that has not maintained its presence in the gaming dialogue. This game combines roguelike mechanics with a compelling sci-fi narrative, showcasing stunning visuals and challenging gameplay. Despite its critical acclaim, the subsequent release of Housemarque's spiritual successor, "Saros," which did not resonate as strongly with players, has contributed to the fading memory of "Returnal."
Reviving Classic Titles in Gaming
"Dishonored," an action-adventure title from Arkane Studios, also deserves mention. Released in 2012, it introduced players to a richly designed steampunk world filled with moral choices and stealth gameplay. Although it received praise upon release and spawned a sequel, the franchise has struggled to maintain relevance in a rapidly evolving gaming landscape, leading to its relegation in discussions about influential games.
Lastly, "Journey," an indie title from Thatgamecompany, captured hearts with its minimalist design and emotional storytelling. While it was groundbreaking at the time of its release in 2012, the lack of new content from the studio has left it in the past, remembered fondly but rarely discussed in current gaming circles.
The Final Take
The fading recognition of these former GOTY winners raises questions about the nature of gaming culture and the industry’s rapid pace. As new titles continuously emerge, even the most celebrated games can become overshadowed, leading to a cycle where only a few titles remain in the public consciousness. Revisiting these games not only highlights their contributions to the medium but also serves as a reminder of the diverse experiences gaming has to offer.
In an industry that thrives on innovation and novelty, the stories of these forgotten Game of the Year winners remind us of the importance of celebrating the past. Each of these titles brought something unique to the gaming landscape, and while they may not dominate current conversations, their impact remains significant. By reflecting on their achievements, we can appreciate the rich tapestry of gaming history and perhaps reignite interest in these remarkable experiences.





